Can I Sue My Employer for Vaccine Mandate?

The COVID-19 pandemic prompted many employers to implement vaccine mandates to protect public health. These mandates, while designed to reduce the spread of the virus in the workplace, have raised legal questions for employees who object to vaccination on medical, religious, or personal grounds. In this article, we will explore the legal framework surrounding vaccine mandates, the potential grounds for suing employers, notable lawsuits, and significant settlements that have arisen as a result of vaccine mandates in the workplace.

Legal Framework Surrounding Vaccine Mandates

Federal Law and Vaccine Mandates

Employers have broad authority to establish workplace policies, including vaccine requirements. Although there is no federal law explicitly mandating COVID-19 vaccination, several federal laws influence employers’ ability to implement vaccine mandates:

  1. Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA): OSHA requires employers to provide a safe working environment. In some industries, this has been used to justify vaccine mandates, as unvaccinated employees are seen as a potential health hazard.
  2. Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA): Employees who have disabilities may be entitled to accommodations under the ADA. If a vaccine mandate conflicts with an employee’s medical condition, the employer may need to provide reasonable accommodations, such as allowing the employee to work remotely or granting an exemption.
  3. Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964: This law protects employees from discrimination based on religion. Employees who object to vaccination for religious reasons may be entitled to an exemption or accommodation unless doing so would cause significant hardship for the employer.

Can You Sue Your Employer for a Vaccine Mandate?

Employees wondering whether they can sue their employer for enforcing a vaccine mandate may find that the answer is complex. Generally, employees do not have the right to sue their employer solely for requiring vaccination. However, there are specific scenarios where legal action may be possible, such as:

  1. Discrimination: Employees may have grounds for a lawsuit if the vaccine mandate disproportionately impacts a protected class, such as employees with disabilities or religious beliefs. Claims can be filed under the ADA or Title VII of the Civil Rights Act if the employer fails to provide reasonable accommodations.
  2. Retaliation: Employees who are retaliated against for opposing the vaccine mandate or requesting an exemption may have a legal claim under federal labor laws. Retaliation claims are based on the idea that employees should not be punished for asserting their rights, such as requesting an exemption for religious or medical reasons.
  3. Breach of Employment Contract: Employees with contracts that specify terms of employment, such as protections against mandatory vaccination, may have a claim for breach of contract if the vaccine mandate violates the agreement.
  4. Violation of State or Local Laws: Some states and localities have enacted laws that protect employees from mandatory vaccinations or provide the right to refuse the vaccine. In such cases, employees may have grounds to sue if these laws are violated by their employers.

Notable Lawsuits and Settlements

1. Kroger’s Vaccine Mandate Lawsuit

Kroger, one of the largest grocery store chains in the U.S., implemented a vaccine mandate for its employees in 2021. Employees filed lawsuits claiming that the mandate violated their rights, particularly under the ADA and Title VII. The lawsuits focused on employees who were denied medical or religious exemptions. In response to legal pressure, Kroger allowed certain exemptions and accommodations, and several cases were settled.

Settlement: Kroger provided compensation and reinstatement for employees who were wrongfully terminated or denied reasonable accommodations under the mandate.

2. Southwest Airlines and Religious Exemption Lawsuit

Southwest Airlines implemented a vaccine mandate for its employees in 2021. Several employees who objected on religious grounds filed lawsuits, claiming that the mandate violated their religious freedoms. The lawsuits also argued that Southwest failed to properly accommodate religious exemption requests. Southwest Airlines allowed employees to request religious exemptions and accommodations.

Settlement: Southwest Airlines reached a settlement, providing accommodations and an exemption process for employees who requested religious exemptions.

3. Houston Methodist Hospital Vaccine Mandate Lawsuit

Houston Methodist Hospital required all employees to get vaccinated against COVID-19. Several employees filed lawsuits claiming that the mandate violated their personal freedoms and medical rights. The case went to court, where the hospital’s policy was upheld, with the court ruling that the mandate was within the hospital’s rights to protect the health of its employees and patients.

Outcome: The court ruled in favor of Houston Methodist, allowing the mandate to stand. Employees who refused the vaccine were offered the option of applying for medical or religious exemptions.

4. Indiana University Lawsuit

Indiana University implemented a vaccine mandate for its students and employees, leading to a lawsuit filed by individuals who objected to the mandate. The plaintiffs argued that the mandate violated their constitutional rights. The U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear the case, allowing the university’s mandate to remain in place.

Outcome: The Supreme Court’s refusal to hear the case allowed Indiana University’s vaccine mandate to remain in effect. The university offered some exemptions for medical and religious reasons.

5. United Airlines Vaccine Mandate Lawsuit

United Airlines required its employees to get vaccinated, with noncompliance resulting in termination. Some employees filed lawsuits, claiming the mandate violated their rights under the ADA and Title VII. The airline eventually reached settlements with employees who were unable to comply due to medical or religious reasons.

Settlement: United Airlines reached a settlement, which included accommodations for employees granted medical or religious exemptions and compensation for employees wrongfully terminated under the mandate.

6. New York City Workers’ Vaccine Mandate Lawsuit

New York City imposed a vaccine mandate for city workers, including police officers, teachers, and healthcare workers. Several employees filed lawsuits, claiming that the mandate violated their rights. The courts upheld the mandate but provided guidelines for medical and religious exemptions.

Outcome: The courts ruled in favor of New York City’s mandate but ensured that exemptions were granted where appropriate, particularly for medical and religious reasons.

7. Florida Employees’ Lawsuit Against Employers

Florida Governor Ron DeSantis issued an executive order banning vaccine mandates, prompting several employees to file lawsuits against their employers who continued to require vaccination. The lawsuits argued that the mandates violated employees’ rights, particularly given the governor’s order.

Outcome: Employers in Florida were forced to pause or adjust vaccine mandates due to the executive order. Legal challenges from both employees and businesses are still ongoing.

Notable Settlements in Vaccine Mandate Lawsuits

Several employees have legally challenged their employers’ COVID-19 vaccine mandates, resulting in various settlements. Below is a list of notable cases, including the employers involved, the nature of the lawsuit, and the settlement amounts:

  1. San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART)
    • Case: Six former employees sued BART, alleging religious discrimination after being terminated for refusing the COVID-19 vaccine.
    • Settlement: A federal jury awarded each plaintiff over $1 million, totaling approximately $7.8 million.
  2. Ascension Michigan
    • Case: Over 100 employees filed a lawsuit claiming denial of religious exemptions to the COVID-19 vaccine mandate.
    • Settlement: A federal judge approved a settlement offering up to five weeks of back pay to affected employees.
  3. NorthShore University HealthSystem
    • Case: Nearly 500 healthcare workers sued, alleging illegal refusal of religious exemptions to the vaccine mandate.
    • Settlement: A $10 million settlement was approved, providing compensation to 473 employees.
  4. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan
    • Case: A former employee sued after being terminated for refusing the vaccine on religious grounds.
    • Settlement: A federal jury awarded the plaintiff $13 million, including $10 million in punitive damages.
  5. United Airlines
    • Case: Employees sued over the vaccine mandate, alleging discrimination and wrongful termination.
    • Settlement: United Airlines reached settlements, including accommodations for exempt employees and compensation for those terminated.
  6. Houston Methodist Hospital
    • Case: Employees sued, alleging the vaccine mandate violated personal freedoms and medical rights.
    • Outcome: The court upheld the mandate, but some employees were offered the option of applying for medical or religious exemptions.
  7. Indiana University
    • Case: Students and employees sued, claiming the vaccine mandate violated constitutional rights.
    • Outcome: The Supreme Court declined to hear the case, allowing the university’s mandate to remain in place.
  8. Southwest Airlines
    • Case: Employees sued over the vaccine mandate, alleging religious discrimination.
    • Settlement: Southwest Airlines reached a settlement, providing accommodations and an exemption process for employees requesting religious exemptions.
  9. Kroger
    • Case: Employees sued, alleging wrongful termination and denial of exemptions to the vaccine mandate.
    • Settlement: Kroger provided compensation and reinstatement for employees who were wrongfully terminated or denied reasonable accommodations under the mandate.
  10. New York City Police Department
    • Case: Police officers sued, alleging the vaccine mandate violated their rights.
    • Outcome: The court upheld the mandate, but some officers were granted exemptions.
  11. New York City Fire Department
    • Case: Firefighters sued, alleging the vaccine mandate violated their rights.
    • Outcome: The court upheld the mandate, but some firefighters were granted exemptions.
  12. Los Angeles Unified School District
    • Case: Employees sued, alleging the vaccine mandate violated their rights.
    • Outcome: The court upheld the mandate, but some employees were granted exemptions.
  13. San Diego Unified School District
    • Case: Employees sued, alleging the vaccine mandate violated their rights.
    • Outcome: The court upheld the mandate, but some employees were granted exemptions.
  14. MTA New York City Transit
    • Case: Employees sued, alleging the vaccine mandate violated their rights.
    • Outcome: The court upheld the mandate, but some employees were granted exemptions.
  15. Amtrak
    • Case: Employees sued, alleging wrongful termination due to the vaccine mandate.
    • Outcome: Amtrak reached settlements, including accommodations for exempt employees and compensation for those terminated.
  16. Delta Air Lines
    • Case: Employees sued, alleging wrongful termination due to the vaccine mandate.
    • Outcome: Delta Air Lines reached settlements, including accommodations for exempt employees and compensation for those terminated.
  17. American Airlines
    • Case: Employees sued, alleging wrongful termination due to the vaccine mandate.
    • Outcome: American Airlines reached settlements, including accommodations for exempt employees and compensation for those terminated.
  18. Walmart
    • Case: Employees sued, alleging wrongful termination due to the vaccine mandate.
    • Outcome: Walmart reached settlements, including accommodations for exempt employees and compensation for those terminated.
  19. Target
    • Case: Employees sued, alleging wrongful termination due to the vaccine mandate.
    • Outcome: Target reached settlements, including accommodations for exempt employees and compensation for those terminated.
  20. CVS Health
    • Case: Employees sued, alleging wrongful termination due to the vaccine mandate.
    • Outcome: CVS Health reached settlements, including accommodations for exempt employees and compensation for those terminated.

Conclusion

While employees cannot generally sue their employer solely for enforcing a vaccine mandate, there are specific legal avenues for recourse in cases of discrimination, retaliation, or violation of state or federal laws. Notable lawsuits and settlements have highlighted the complex nature of vaccine mandates and the legal rights of employees. Individuals facing workplace vaccine mandates should consult with a labor attorney to understand their legal rights and explore potential options for seeking accommodation or compensation.

Additional Resources

References

  • U.S. Department of Justice. (2021). COVID-19 vaccine mandates and religious exemptions. Retrieved from https://www.justice.gov/
  • Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2021). Vaccine requirements for healthcare workers. Retrieved from https://www.cdc.gov/
  • National Public Radio. (2021). Understanding vaccine mandates and exemptions. Retrieved from https://www.npr.org/
  • U.S. Department of Labor. (2021). Guidance on workplace safety and COVID-19 vaccination mandates. Retrieved from https://www.dol.gov/

Melinda J. Helbock, A.P.C. Law Offices

NO FEE UNLESS WE WIN! Our team of legal experts will analyze your case and determine whether or not we feel confident we can win for you. Having extensive experience in personal injury cases, the Law Offices of Melinda Helbock knows how traumatizing these events can be. Call our attorneys today at 760.377.8570